Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

In Alamo Heights, Teardowns Keep Getting Approved. The Calendar Is the Real Gate.

On Monday, November 9, the Alamo Heights City Council is scheduled to take up the house at 131 Mary D Ave a second time. The owner plans to demolish all of the existing structure and build a new single-family home. The case first went to the Architectural Review Board on September 15, and the board tabled it. On October 12, Council heard a related appeal asking to split the city's two demolition reviews and tabled that one too, moving it to November 9. On October 20, the ARB declared the house "not significant" and recommended the proposed design as compatible.

The case moved slowly, but the house never got close to being saved. The same is true across 2026. Alamo Heights' demolition review has added months to projects without stopping any of them.

Ten months of decisions, one outcome

From January through October 2026, every house that came before the ARB for a significance decision was declared "not significant." No house drew a demolition delay, and no replacement design was ruled incompatible. One October case was approved with conditions. The cases that went all the way through Council show how long the second step takes:

Address Scope of work ARB action Council approval Days between
280 Tuxedo Ave About 36% of a street façade plus the entire roof Feb 17 Mar 9 20
305 Argo Ave, 310 Lamont Ave, 215 Morse St Full demolitions Mar 17 Apr 13 27
202 Rosemary Ave Partial project Mar 17 Apr 13 27
607 Evans Ave Full demolition Apr 21 May 11 20
217 Corona Ave, 126 College Blvd Full demolitions Jun 16 Jul 13 27
216 Grant Ave Compatibility review for a new home Jun 16 Jul 13 27
200 Primrose Pl Full demolition Sep 15 Sep 28 13

The house at 231 Encino Ave had a very different experience two years earlier. In early 2024, San Antonio Report covered the dispute over the 1922 house at that address. The outlet later reported that Council imposed a 90-day cooling-off period after the ARB found the house significant. In April 2026, the ARB recommended a compatible design for 231 Encino, and Council approved it on May 11.

What the 2024 rewrite moved to the front of the process

The demolition rules are in Chapter 5, Article IX of the Alamo Heights Code of Ordinances. They date to Ordinance 1860 in April 2010, and Ordinance 2222 amended them on June 10, 2024. The 2024 amendment added a sentence to §5-134(b): "The significance and compatibility process may not be completed in separate processes."

The code has two questions. Significance asks whether the existing house matters. The factors include age, a noted architect, a historic listing, a distinctive style, and importance to the community fabric, and the code sets no minimum age. Compatibility asks whether the replacement fits the project block, the blocks on either side, and the blocks directly across the street. The ARB weighs scale, height, massing, lot coverage, setbacks, materials, roof pitch and landscaping.

In 2026, owners asked Council to waive the combined review again and again:

  • 123 Ogden Ln: variance to separate the reviews for a 100% demolition, approved 5–0 on April 13
  • 511 La Jara Blvd: approved May 11
  • 336 Corona Ave: approved June 8
  • 6715 Broadway St: variance to separate the reviews for a 100% demolition, approved 5–0 on October 12
  • 131 Mary D Ave: tabled to November 9

These approvals cover the order of the review, not the final demolition. Still, the requests say a lot. With every 2026 house ruled not significant, owners were not trying to avoid losing their case. They were asking to learn the answer before paying for the design.

The city's own Demolition Review page still describes two steps and estimates about 30 days. The page was posted in March 2025, after the 2024 amendment, and its 30-day estimate is shorter than the calendar in some 2026 cases described below.

The clock, and what restarts it

The current case at 118 Routt St is an addition that removes about 51.62% of the street-facing façade.

The ARB usually meets on the third Tuesday of the month at 5:30 p.m. at City Hall, 6116 Broadway. Its role is advisory.

431 Ogden Ln went into its notice period on October 30, is set for the ARB on November 17, and is set for Council on December 14. 118 Routt St started its comment period on August 3 and was rescheduled from August 18 and again from September 15. It cleared the ARB on October 20 and goes to Council on November 9, 98 days after notice began. The house was ruled not significant, and the delay still added about two months.

A separate historic district effort

The ordinance says it "is not intended to permanently prevent demolition." The city's broader effort to create historic districts is a separate matter. The San Antonio Business Journal reported in May 2026 that the city had paused it after a series of demolitions drew public backlash.

FAQ

Where are the current cases posted? The city's Public Notices and Plans page lists active ARB cases, comment periods and hearing dates. The ARB page has agendas and results.

Who decides, the ARB or Council? The ARB makes a recommendation, and Council makes the final decision.

This article covers city rules as they are published. It is general information, not legal advice, so confirm how the ordinance applies to your property with the city and a qualified professional.

If you're weighing a teardown or a large addition in Alamo Heights, BGA Design + Build can work with you. Contact BGA Design + Build.

Work With Us

At BGA Design + Build, we believe a home is not just a building—it's a dream come to life. Nestled in the scenic Texas locales of Boerne, Fair Oaks Ranch, and Canyon Lake, each home we craft is a reflection of our passion. Understanding that your home is likely your most significant investment, we are committed to ensuring it embodies your highest aspirations. Partner with us and transform your vision into a stunning reality in these beautiful regions.

CONTACT US